Story Creature

Odysseus tied to the mast of his ship to keep from steering towards the sirens.

God created Adam and Eve in God’s image and every human being who has ever lived reflects this – the imago dei. This means we create because our God is creative; we tell stories because God is a storyteller.
Stories are a fitting medium for a God who is called the Word. Whether it’s written down in Scripture, incarnate in Jesus Christ, or eternally upholding the universe, God is telling a story. And God’s creatures, likewise, can’t seem to help themselves. Despite the distortion of the Fall, humanity continues to create stories within God’s grand narrative, yearning for resolution and restoration. People have been playing variations on the same themes for millennia: creation, fall, and redemption have been stamped all over our stories.
Our first stories were spoken aloud. The ancient Greeks, for example, told the story of Odysseus and his long road home from Troy over and over again until Homer wrote it down in the late 17th or early 18th century BC. In this epic poem, Odysseus eventually reunites with his family and defeats those who threaten to take everything from him. This isn’t what generations of hearers and readers remember, though. Odysseus lives on because of his longing. Today, an “odyssey” doesn’t refer to a triumphant return; it means “a long wandering or voyage usually marked by many changes of fortune.” Even if the ancient Greek experience is foreign, there is a deposit of truth: humanity longs for home.
Eighteen hundred years later, a poet with one foot in paganism and one in Christianity told a story of strength and heroism – the epic Beowulf. Yet, for all its grandeur and glory, Beowulf is a sad story. The hero triumphs over monsters, wins the love of his people, and even reaches a ripe old age, but something is wrong.
For all his great deeds, Beowulf still succumbs to the final enemy: death. Human glory is extinguished and the reader is left wondering does it have to be this way, must death be the end? Some of the greatest moments in literature turn on the reversal of this curse, this darkness that has hung over us since the first sin. Our heroes rail against death because it ought not to be the rule of the world, not forever.
The first meeting of Aragorn and Arwen, characters from “The Lord of the Rings,” by Anke Eissmann.

There’s great continuity in storytelling. Just as we have been exploring the same themes, so too do we look for stories that echo – and anticipate – the biblical narrative. When J. R. R. Tolkien wrote The Lord of the Rings, he did so to reflect the creative nature of God. He created Middle-earth to reflect our Earth. Like ours, Middle-earth is a good world marred by evil – it is full of blessings and curses. It reminds us that the world is a dark place, “but still there is much that is fair, and though in all lands love is now mingled with grief, it grows perhaps the greater.”
When a crown-less king says “deeds will not be less valiant because they are unpraised” or an immortal elf lord declares that small hands move the wheels of the world, I believe it because I need to. And I can believe it because there is a power above the oppressive powers of the world. The story makes its case for this truth by elevating the good, the simple, and the small in ways reminiscent of Christ’s upside down kingdom. Jesus illustrates the nature of his kingdom in the parables of the prodigal son and the lost coin. God pursues those who are considered least worthy, like the single coin and the ungrateful runaway; God rejoices over them – not the righteous.
God’s story climaxes in redemption and ends in restoration, the fruit of eucatastrophe, Tolkien’s word for the sudden and unexpected good turn in a story. The rule of the world is not death and death becomes an aberration. The gospel is a call to tell better stories that echo the greatest story. In the past we told these stories in part, and we continue to do so by weaving the threads of creation, fall, and redemption into stories for our time. Films like Mad Max: Fury Road trace an arc of redemption across a fallen world, while others like Ex Machina examine the costs of human creativity, and like all good stories they refuse to ignore the consequences of sin. For his part, Tolkien believed we will continue telling stories even after hearing God’s own: “Story, fantasy, still go on, and should go on. The Evangelium has not abrogated legends; it has hallowed them, especially the ‘happy ending.’”
The truth of the even the most unbelievable stories is apparent in the moment when the spell of a story is broken from outside, when the light of truth leaks through the page or frame and offers hope. Our imaginary worlds are acquainted with the darkness of fear, loss, and death, just as we are, and this reality sets the stage for the great reversal of eucatasrophe. Life overcomes death; love overwhelms hate; light dispels darkness just in time. Good stories are true because they remind us there is light beyond the darkness; the best story reminds us that the light shines in the darkness.

Matt Civico is a freelance writer from Montreal, QC, where he and his wife do their best to prize food and cheer and song above hoarded gold. He blogs at and is also a staff writer for Area of Effect magazine.


Keep on reading...


Dismantling Anti-Black Racism in the Diocese of Rupert’s Land

Header Photo: Shreyas Kakad This is an incomplete segment of an ongoing piece on the Black Anglicans of Rupert’s Land, Diocese of Rupertsland chapter and …


September 2023: Fruits of the Spirit

What would a society based on the fruits of the spirit look like? What kind of vulnerability and courage would it take to let go …


What Do You Believe?: Prison Abolition and the Quaker Tradition

Header Photo: Markus Spiske By: John Samson Fellows An earlier version of this article was originally published in Quaker Concern by Canadian Friends Service Committee. …

Skip to content